Beneath the euphoria of triumph lies the harder question: is this ceasefire peace, or merely the pause before another cycle of proxy war?
The guns are momentarily silent. Operation Sindoor; India’s audacious, overwhelming victory over Pakistan, has redrawn South Asia’s strategic landscape. Islamabad stands isolated, its military humbled, its propaganda punctured. New Delhi basks in national pride, celebrated by allies, watched closely by rivals. Yet beneath the euphoria of triumph lies the harder question: is this ceasefire peace, or merely the pause before another cycle of proxy war?
Victory’s Fragile Shadow
India’s strike was conclusive: Pakistan was battered into suspension of hostilities, its narrative of parity with India shattered. But a cornered adversary is not a pacified one. Pakistan’s history has shown that defeat on the battlefield often births new theatres of invisible war; terror-by-proxy, disinformation campaigns, covert destabilisation. And the chosen crucible has always been Kashmir.
Here lies the paradox. Formal conflict exposes Pakistan’s weaknesses: a collapsing economy, hollow institutions, public disillusionment. But peace is equally perilous for its ruling elite. For 75 years, the establishment has masked failure by crying “India danger.” With that mask stripped away, Islamabad must answer for its decrepit economy, its crumbling hospitals and schools, its disillusioned youth. To avoid this reckoning, the temptation to ‘restart the fires in Kashmir’ is almost irresistible.
Kashmir: Silence, Fear, and the Proxy War Nexus
The Valley is a wounded landscape, scarred by decades of brainwashing that painted India as an enemy and separatism as a romance. While the ‘peaceful majority remains silent’, Pakistan’s terror ecosystem fills the void: Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Mohammed, and newer fronts like The Resistance Front (TRF). With cross-border artillery muted, these groups must prove their relevance through ‘selective strikes, assassinations of civilians, attacks on security personnel’; tactically small but psychologically potent.
The Baisaran massacre remains an open wound. The four killers, delayed justice, underscore the gaps militants exploit: weak intelligence closure, fragmented counter-terrorism response, and community fear. Each such episode erodes the promise of stability.
Even more insidious is Pakistan’s narco-terror project. Synthetic drugs, smuggled cough syrups, illicit trades, these poison South Kashmir’s youth. Drugs serve a dual function: funding terror and corroding social fabric. Cultural decay, erosion of piety, rise of prostitution, spread of addiction; is as much a weapon as the Kalashnikov. The stakes are not simply territorial, they are civilisational. Can a culture grounded in poetry, piety and resilience be rescued from this deliberate corrosion?
Pakistan’s Existential Reckoning
Sindoor has pierced Islamabad’s oldest armour—its projection of “eternal victimhood.” Now exposed globally and vulnerable domestically, Pakistan faces an existential test. Its military-ISI elite cannot sustain the same script. But neither can they pivot easily. They sit on a double-edged sword:
- If they pursue peace, their internal rot is exposed. Questions of jobs, infrastructure, education arise.
- If they revive war, they risk annihilation; militarily, diplomatically, perhaps even territorially.
This paradox may push Pakistan towards a calibrated “gray war”: proxy terror, semi-deniable violence, digital propaganda, jihad rebranded for a new generation. The frontlines may shift to Jammu, Poonch-Rajouri, or even hinterland urban centres, provocations designed to bleed India without triggering outright retaliation.
The Euphoria Trap
For India, Sindoor’s success is incontestable. For the first time, the might of its defence complex has been displayed with clarity: indigenous systems meshed with global alliances, BrahMos batteries unflinching, intelligence coordination precise. India has entered the world’s imagination not merely as a balancing power, but as a ‘decisive actor.’
But celebrations can be a trap. The ‘spectacle of victory’, intoxicating as it is, may lead to complacency or an endless loop of operations. History warns: wars secure days, but peace demands decades. If India merely outguns Pakistan while Beijing discreetly refuels it, the cycle will spin again. True victory is not conquest but incapacitation; ensuring terror can never again be wielded as state policy. That requires dismantling financial pipelines, rupturing ideological cradles, and exposing Pakistan’s internal failings to its own citizens.
The Kashmir Imperative: Belonging, Not Just Security
Military campaigns suppress militancy, but they cannot erase its memory. Kashmir’s transformation rests not in securing borders alone but in embedding prosperity deep into civilian life. Schools that inspire, hospitals that function, jobs that anchor dignity, these demolish the mythology of separatism more thoroughly than bullets ever could.
Equally critical is amplifying the peaceful majority. The silence of moderates has allowed extremist voices to dominate. By empowering civic groups, local entrepreneurs, artists, and community leaders, New Delhi must flip the narrative: from grievance to growth, from separatism to belonging.
The real antidote to radicalisation is an identity that makes separatism irrelevant. When a Kashmiri youth sees more future in coding startups, universities, or tourism enterprises than in picking up a gun, victory will have transcended the battlefield.
Vishwaguru or Endless Vortex?
Operation Sindoor projects India’s arrival as more than a regional power. It signals to the Global South a third choice between Western hegemony and Chinese authoritarianism. As a rising defence manufacturer and moral force, India can step into the role of a Vishwaguru: a nation that secures its borders, but also articulates peace as destiny.
Yet, this mantle is fragile. Vishwaguru cannot be claimed through triumphalism alone. It must be earned by transforming Kashmir into a laboratory of peace and by breaking Pakistan’s ideology of hate, not merely through weapons but through wisdom, resilience, and example.
The Road Ahead
The ceasefire is no victory lap; it is a responsibility test. India’s task is triple:
1. Neutralise Pakistan’s terror architecture: financially, operationally, ideologically.
2. Invest in Kashmir’s human capital: Cultural revival, jobs, schools, healthcare, dignity.
3. Resist the narcotic of euphoria: recognising that stability, not revenge, is the true endgame.
For Pakistan, the horizon is harsher. Seventy-five years of hate-politics have eroded its core. Unless it breaks from its addiction to terror, peace will be impossible. For Kashmir, the stakes are generational. Silence can no longer be an option. A region that once gave the world its most exquisite poetry cannot allow itself to be defined by narcotics and nihilism.
In the end, Sindoor will be remembered not for the bombs that fell, but for what India chooses to build in their aftermath. If handled with precision, objectivity, and vision, it may mark not just the defeat of Pakistan’s terror nexus but the rebirth of Kashmir as a bastion of harmony.
The horizon stands clear: India’s greatness will not be measured by how thoroughly it punished Pakistan, but by how convincingly it secured peace.
About The Author
